Discussion " National Exam "

 

Yesterday I have been followed Debating in MELC and the Topic is "National Exam" you know we devided into two groups

there are some important point which I've got
some debate include the primary questions such as : does the quality of Indonesia Education depend on National Exam??. Will the quality of Indonesia Education system worse witahout National Exam??


Pro >>
poeple who support the National Exam explain that the quality of Indonesia Education will drop without national Exam because Indonesia have bad system About National Education
in fact, ABI said that We cannot put the blame on National Examination Because because National Examination can still be usefull as an instrument as evaluate or defect the level of student's cognetive competence in severeal subject, on a national scale 


Cons>>


people who do not support the National Exam said that National Exam is Not effective to measure the capabily of students because when they face national Exam . students like got pressure psychological.


Pro >>
It not about preasuse which get by National Exam beacuse they have been learnt for third  years and they must follow the national exam. ready or not you have to ready..beacuse National Exam seems like easy if you really love education and you wanna continue to  the next level like university


Cons>>


indeed there is no problem in system of Indonesia education but we have to modified it again??


Pro>>


if you say like that , it's mean that you agreed with National Exam, right ??


MR Topic said  for us that we have to deffer our debating and MR topic gave us 10 minutes to give the main point why you support National Examination ???? and why you do not support National Exam ????


The main Point of Pro
firstly, National  Examination necessary as a control for the extent to which a school have implemented the national education program properly. Thus, the output of national examination is a success indication of a school in implementing the national education curricula
secondly, Indonesia has rule about National Exam and you could see on UUD No 20 tahu 2003
thirdly, we cannot put the blame on the national exam


the main point of Cons

firstly.National Exam national exam can be bad for psychiatric students because National exam like a monster
Secondly, by National Exam we Cannot measure the capability of students
thirdly,, we have repair the system of National Education




it's my experience when I followed debating in MELC.. I will be back again with other topic